{ "_meta": { "purpose": "Data dictionary for every anomaly/glitch type. confidence: confirmed=byte/chain proven; eye=the collector visual; heuristic=automated rule (AUDIT); mixed/unknown.", "updated": "2026-08-27", "n_types": 145 }, "types": [ { "type": "note", "label": "note", "def": "Free-text observation from the collector's own visual pass. Reliability = his eye; content varies per piece.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "the collector's eye-notes file", "n": 323, "members": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 11, 12, 15, 17, 18, 19, 23, 25, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 44, 45, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 53, 56, 58, 59, 60, 61, 66, 67, 71, 73, 75, 78, 79, 83, 84, 86, 89, 90, 97, 100, 101, 102, 103, 107, 109, 113, 115, 117, 123, 127, 129, 130, 133, 136, 138, 140, 141, 142, 143, 146, 147, 148, 151, 152, 153, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163, 165, 166, 168, 170, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 178, 180, 181, 182, 183, 185, 187, 188, 190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209, 210, 211, 217, 228, 231, 244, 256, 259, 268, 274, 281, 287, 291, 300, 301, 302, 303, 304, 305, 306, 307, 308, 309, 310, 311, 312, 313, 314, 315, 316, 317, 318, 319, 320, 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326, 327, 328, 329, 330, 331, 332, 333, 334, 335, 336, 337, 338, 339, 340, 341, 342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 347, 348, 349, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357, 358, 359, 360, 361, 362, 363, 364, 365, 366, 367, 368, 369, 370, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375, 376, 377, 378, 379, 380, 381, 382, 383, 384, 385, 386, 387, 388, 389, 390, 391, 392, 393, 394, 395, 396, 397, 398, 399, 401, 402, 403, 404, 405, 406, 407, 408, 409, 410, 411, 412, 413, 414, 415, 416, 417, 418, 419, 420, 421, 422, 423, 424, 425, 426, 427, 428, 429, 430, 431, 432, 433, 434, 435, 436, 437, 438, 439, 440, 441, 442, 443, 444, 447, 449, 450, 451, 452, 454, 455, 456, 462, 463, 464, 465, 466, 467, 468, 469, 473, 474, 475, 476, 479, 480, 481, 482, 483, 484, 485, 486, 487, 488, 489, 490, 491, 492, 493, 494, 495, 496, 497, 501, 502, 503, 504, 505, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:No on-chain traits", "label": "No on-chain traits", "def": "The on-chain metadata CACHE (Blockscout) returned no attributes for this piece when we pulled it. This is a cache artifact spread evenly across drops — NOT a property of the piece; the full chain record exists and carries all traits. Kept only as a data-provenance note.", "confidence": "meta", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 120, "members": [ 0, 4, 28, 30, 31, 39, 41, 43, 47, 55, 57, 63, 80, 82, 88, 97, 100, 104, 114, 119, 121, 126, 127, 131, 134, 142, 143, 146, 150, 160, 161, 166, 172, 184, 192, 199, 211, 215, 218, 219, 223, 228, 231, 233, 234, 238, 248, 261, 263, 269, 270, 271, 276, 287, 288, 293, 295, 296, 299, 301, 307, 313, 319, 322, 326, 327, 339, 340, 344, 346, 347, 350, 351, 359, 362, 364, 366, 368, 369, 371, 372, 379, 384, 399, 408, 409, 412, 419, 430, 434, 451, 456, 457, 458, 459, 460, 461, 462, 463, 464, 465, 466, 467, 468, 475, 479, 480, 484, 490, 492, 493, 497, 498, 499, 500, 501, 506, 508, 509, 512 ], "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "xmp:dotted_resave", "label": "xmp:dotted_resave", "def": "The file was re-exported from a LIVE Photoshop document after the original export (the hidden XMP metadata carries a dotted tool version — 22.3/22.5/23.0/23.1 — and mismatched document IDs). 77 files were touched this way, clustering into exactly eleven re-save sessions. Pindar went back and re-saved these pieces after making them.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 77, "members": [ 7, 11, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47, 53, 59, 61, 67, 71, 73, 79, 83, 97, 101, 103, 107, 109, 113, 127, 129, 130, 147, 159, 203, 211, 213, 230, 231, 239, 244, 246, 256, 264, 266, 270, 274, 286, 287, 291, 294, 300, 302, 315, 337, 340, 342, 365, 368, 373, 383, 386, 396, 403, 407, 408, 425, 426, 439, 446, 447, 453, 454, 457, 460, 461, 465, 466, 479, 480, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "flag:Visual Space Invader", "label": "Visual Space Invader", "def": "Automated census category ('Visual Space Invader') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 34, "members": [ 302, 310, 314, 315, 320, 337, 340, 349, 365, 368, 370, 372, 373, 375, 377, 379, 383, 386, 396, 398, 401, 403, 408, 412, 425, 426, 431, 439, 465, 466, 473, 474, 475, 476 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Burnt in forge", "label": "Burnt in forge", "def": "Sent to the burn wallet (0xa7c2…1a0c) before the clue existed. The wallet holds 32 items: 30 Act-1 bitGANs plus 2 pieces from OTHER collections ('Noun GAN Study (3/63)' and 'reneGANs 0110 - Cyber roboGANs') — cross-collection burns fed the forges too. Verify against opensea.io/burntGANs.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 30, "members": [ 2, 9, 11, 20, 32, 33, 49, 66, 69, 74, 86, 87, 95, 111, 117, 123, 125, 135, 138, 144, 149, 153, 168, 194, 198, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "burnt", "label": "burnt", "def": "Chain-verified burn: the piece was transferred to the burn wallet 0xa7c2…1a0c before the clue existed. 30 of the 512 were burnt; the wallet holds 32 items total (2 are from other collections).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "burnt_final.json", "n": 29, "members": [ 2, 9, 11, 20, 32, 33, 49, 69, 74, 86, 87, 95, 111, 117, 123, 125, 135, 138, 144, 149, 153, 168, 194, 198, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "flag:Frame-count anomaly", "label": "Frame-count anomaly", "def": "Automated census category ('Frame-count anomaly') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 29, "members": [ 129, 132, 146, 147, 155, 159, 162, 163, 165, 166, 169, 180, 182, 183, 192, 228, 246, 264, 282, 445, 446, 467, 468, 469, 493, 494, 495, 496, 512 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "flag:Essence MEANS a glitch", "label": "Essence MEANS a glitch", "def": "Automated census category ('Essence MEANS a glitch') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 26, "members": [ 51, 57, 131, 135, 139, 142, 143, 146, 168, 182, 187, 191, 307, 328, 342, 358, 363, 404, 431, 468, 473, 495, 500, 503, 504, 507 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "flag:the collector: visually novel (no other drop)", "label": "the collector: visually novel (no other drop)", "def": "Automated census category ('the collector: visually novel (no other drop)') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 23, "members": [ 467, 468, 469, 485, 486, 487, 488, 497, 498, 499, 500, 501, 502, 503, 504, 505, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Chain contradicts sheet", "label": "Chain contradicts sheet", "def": "Automated census category ('Chain contradicts sheet') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 20, "members": [ 16, 17, 33, 44, 48, 58, 59, 62, 66, 73, 81, 123, 124, 128, 173, 175, 281, 290, 309, 315 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "signature_violator", "label": "signature_violator", "def": "Name-vs-reality mismatch (art doesn't match what the name/GANg implies). the collector-endorsed subset.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "signature_dictionary.md", "n": 17, "members": [ 92, 96, 116, 166, 179, 186, 204, 232, 233, 254, 276, 340, 381, 395, 478, 491, 505 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "label" }, { "type": "flag:Name contains BIP39 word", "label": "Name contains BIP39 word", "def": "The piece has a PROPER-NAME title (one that breaks the standard \"SubType Type GANg\" naming formula — e.g. \"Dr Awkward\", \"The Artist\") and that proper name contains a valid BIP-39 seed word. Ordinary formula names also contain BIP words (ghost, smoke…) but those are drop vocabulary, not authored word-plants; this flag marks only the formula-breakers. 16 pieces qualify.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 16, "members": [ 2, 141, 147, 159, 174, 180, 309, 327, 370, 374, 383, 404, 445, 449, 496, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Essence is puzzle-meta", "label": "Essence is puzzle-meta", "def": "Automated census category ('Essence is puzzle-meta') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 15, "members": [ 78, 153, 168, 169, 336, 360, 363, 367, 389, 391, 411, 450, 453, 473, 474 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "flag:Named after person/entity", "label": "Named after person/entity", "def": "Automated census category ('Named after person/entity') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 14, "members": [ 1, 2, 3, 210, 211, 228, 246, 264, 282, 445, 446, 447, 448, 482 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Leet-corrupted title", "label": "Leet-corrupted title", "def": "Automated census category ('Leet-corrupted title') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 13, "members": [ 131, 136, 137, 140, 142, 145, 146, 148, 158, 170, 172, 182, 188 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "flag:Chain is the corrupt side", "label": "Chain is the corrupt side", "def": "For this piece, the ON-CHAIN copy of a specific trait holds a corrupted value while the published sheet holds the clean one — the corruption lives on the blockchain side. Each piece's record names the exact field and both values (e.g. #16: chain name reads 'Primoridal', sheet reads 'Primordial'). Exactly eleven pieces have the chain as the corrupt side.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 11, "members": [ 16, 17, 44, 48, 58, 62, 66, 81, 173, 281, 309 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Name vs GANg mismatch", "label": "Name vs GANg mismatch", "def": "Automated census category ('Name vs GANg mismatch') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 10, "members": [ 39, 154, 210, 211, 420, 474, 498, 502, 503, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "label" }, { "type": "axis:eye_structure", "label": "eye_structure", "def": "Eye-type taxonomy: skull=empty w/ cut bottom-inside corner; robo=square WITH pupils; ghost=square NO pupil; noun=#147 only; oval=large pupils.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "glitch_types axes", "n": 10, "members": [ 191, 206, 228, 447, 468, 469, 474, 475, 476, 506 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "wrong_creature", "label": "wrong_creature", "def": "Rare species/creature for its drop (e.g. a shark in the skull drop).", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "drop_thematist", "n": 10, "members": [ 5, 8, 13, 89, 130, 209, 300, 327, 407, 507 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "confirmed_glitch", "label": "confirmed_glitch", "def": "Byte/structurally confirmed glitch (splice, negative-frame, timing hold, double-mint, identity copy).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "confirmed_glitch_registry.md", "n": 9, "members": [ 14, 47, 75, 146, 281, 390, 479, 480, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Visual statistical outlier", "label": "Visual statistical outlier", "def": "Automated census category ('Visual statistical outlier') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 9, "members": [ 97, 228, 251, 287, 362, 396, 482, 494, 507 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:HiddenType F (undocumented)", "label": "HiddenType F (undocumented)", "def": "The 'F' HiddenType value. In the robo drop F is the legitimate 6th class = the eight binary-palindrome positions (the nagas). In spooky, #193 alone carries F at position 0. HiddenType is Pindar's on-chain number-class code: a=Fibonacci, b=prime, c=square, d=odd-composite, e=even, applied on each drop's native numbering (skull=decimal, robo=binary position with F=palindrome override, spooky=octal). Decoded 2026-08-31.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 9, "members": [ 129, 141, 147, 159, 162, 174, 180, 192, 193 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "flag:the collector: tagged Outlier", "label": "the collector: tagged Outlier", "def": "Automated census category ('the collector: tagged Outlier') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 9, "members": [ 465, 466, 467, 468, 469, 497, 498, 499, 500 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Art contradicts SubType", "label": "Art contradicts SubType", "def": "Automated census category ('Art contradicts SubType') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 8, "members": [ 81, 150, 231, 326, 343, 490, 509, 511 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "label" }, { "type": "flag:the collector: CORRUPTED type", "label": "the collector: CORRUPTED type", "def": "Automated census category ('the collector: CORRUPTED type') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 7, "members": [ 505, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Missing/malformed file", "label": "Missing/malformed file", "def": "Automated census category ('Missing/malformed file') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 6, "members": [ 57, 134, 143, 446, 472, 477 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "flag:Metadata typo", "label": "Metadata typo", "def": "Automated census category ('Metadata typo') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 6, "members": [ 73, 123, 128, 170, 175, 205 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "whitespace", "label": "whitespace", "def": "Selective extra whitespace in chain name (invisible on display).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "exact-case chain names", "n": 6, "members": [ 194, 202, 203, 204, 207, 208 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "glitch_type:figure_resemblance", "label": "glitch_type:figure_resemblance", "def": "The art briefly resembles a recognizable figure or animal that has nothing to do with its label: a whale (#5), a shark (#89), a bird/parrot (#268), a space-invader head (#302, #465, #466).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 6, "members": [ 5, 89, 268, 302, 465, 466 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flag:Essence out of sequence", "label": "Essence out of sequence", "def": "Automated census category. A piece whose essence sits outside its drop's wordlist-order run. Now two pieces only: #21 'bean' and #57 'mistake', whose indices (157, 1136) match their words. #259 and #268 were filed here until Pindar's own index column showed they are a transposed pair (essence_transposed), not displacements. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 4, "members": [ 21, 57, 259, 268 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "axis:wrong_drop_identity", "label": "wrong_drop_identity", "def": "Pieces wearing another drop's identity/features (misplaced-looking).", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "glitch_types axes", "n": 4, "members": [ 187, 191, 447, 506 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "xmp:solstice_23_stragglers", "label": "xmp:solstice_23_stragglers", "def": "Saved OUTSIDE the main Solstice-drop export burst (Dec 18, 16:22-16:46) with a Photoshop 23.0 tool — a handful of stragglers Pindar exported separately from the batch.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 4, "members": [ 239, 246, 264, 300 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "flag:Filename typo", "label": "Filename typo", "def": "Automated census category ('Filename typo') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 3, "members": [ 9, 73, 128 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "case_anomaly", "label": "case_anomaly", "def": "Chain name capitalization deviates from family convention (e.g. suffix 'Gan' not 'GAN').", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "exact-case chain names", "n": 3, "members": [ 88, 175, 205 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "flag:Corrupted essence", "label": "Corrupted essence", "def": "The Essence value itself is malformed: #191's 'err0r' (a zero where the letter o belongs — the only non-word essence in 512) and #363/#473 whose essences render as the spreadsheet booleans TRUE/FALSE (valid seed words wearing a data-format costume).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 3, "members": [ 191, 363, 473 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "xmp:early_act1review_trio", "label": "xmp:early_act1review_trio", "def": "Authored 2021-10-23/24 — roughly THREE MONTHS before every other Act 1 Review file (Jan 2022), right after the spooky drop. Three pieces (#467-#469) existed long before their drop.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 3, "members": [ 467, 468, 469 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "xmp:skull_late_pair", "label": "xmp:skull_late_pair", "def": "Saved on 2021-08-24, DAYS after every other plain skull file (Aug 20-21). Only #1 The Moirai and #121 share this late save — the first piece and a twin, revisited together.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 1, 121 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "typo_name", "label": "typo_name", "def": "Chain name contains a misspelling/transposition (e.g. 'Primoridal').", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "exact-case chain names", "n": 2, "members": [ 16, 100 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "flag:HiddenType rule violation", "label": "HiddenType rule violation", "def": "A piece whose HiddenType contradicts its number-class = an authored misfile. Exactly four exist: #32 & #161 hold the literal '32' where a letter belongs (both resolve to the number 32); #119 is odd but filed 'e'/even (Pindar-flagged); #187 is even but filed 'c'/square. HiddenType is Pindar's on-chain number-class code: a=Fibonacci, b=prime, c=square, d=odd-composite, e=even, applied on each drop's native numbering (skull=decimal, robo=binary position with F=palindrome override, spooky=octal). Decoded 2026-08-31.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 2, "members": [ 32, 187 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "flag:Pindar-flagged anomaly", "label": "Pindar-flagged anomaly", "def": "Automated census category ('Pindar-flagged anomaly') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 2, "members": [ 32, 119 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "glitch_type:standard_glitch", "label": "glitch_type:standard_glitch", "def": "The baseline visual glitch of the collection: a foreign (or repeated) frame spliced into the animation loop — the skull drop's native glitch dialect.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 47, 140 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "label_ambiguous", "label": "label_ambiguous", "def": "SubType/label partially fits but has a contradicting passage; needs eye ratification.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "the collector", "n": 2, "members": [ 150, 511 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "label" }, { "type": "glitch_type:sits_behind_binary", "label": "glitch_type:sits_behind_binary", "def": "The creature sits BEHIND the binary/background layer instead of in front of it — the digits render over the body. A structural robo-drop signature (and the stage for the white-zero-eyes discovery).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 178, 188 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "xmp:solstice_lone_days", "label": "xmp:solstice_lone_days", "def": "Saved alone on an isolated day (Dec 9 or Dec 11), apart from the main Solstice export session — a file Pindar handled on its own.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 228, 282 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "glitch_type:twin_entangled", "label": "glitch_type:twin_entangled", "def": "Early combined tag for twin/entangled pieces, from before the collector's D7 ruling split them: TWIN = two side-by-side bodies that never merge; ENTANGLED = bodies intermingled. Superseded by the ratified classes but kept for record lineage.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 244, 281 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chain_mismatch", "label": "chain_mismatch", "def": "On-chain trait/name differs from the published properties sheet.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "chain_mismatches.json", "n": 2, "members": [ 404, 420 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "glitch_type:no_glitch", "label": "glitch_type:no_glitch", "def": "(glitch_type:no_glitch) — definition pending.", "confidence": "meta", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 15, 25 ], "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "glitch_type:larger_eyes", "label": "glitch_type:larger_eyes", "def": "The eyes grow noticeably larger than the drop's normal proportions, sometimes only for a few frames.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 18, 37 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "xmp:byte_identical_pair", "label": "xmp:byte_identical_pair", "def": "The two files are BYTE-IDENTICAL down to their hidden XMP document IDs — the only ID reuse in the whole corpus. #14 and #75 are literally the same file published twice.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 14, 75 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "xmp:primes_missing", "label": "xmp:primes_missing", "def": "The 22.3 re-save batch contains every prime-numbered skull from 7 to 127 EXCEPT these (#13, #89) — the only primes left in the plain Aug-20 session. The re-save sessions themselves track prime numbers (compare the Prime Rule).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 2, "members": [ 13, 89 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "near_miss_homage", "label": "near_miss_homage", "def": "Art almost renders as another entity (invader, Sol/Luna, an artist motif) but never completes.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "the collector 2026-08-27", "n": 2, "members": [ 357, 423 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "glitch_type:unique_eyes", "label": "glitch_type:unique_eyes", "def": "A one-of-a-kind eye rendering: #147's Noun-study eyes (only one in the collection), #161's static green-rimmed eyes, #187's first-of-its-kind ghost eye structure.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 187 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "name_anomaly", "label": "name_anomaly", "def": "Something in this piece's exact on-chain name deviates from its drop's naming formula — a miscased letter, a transposed word, unexpected spacing, or a wrong-base number. Byte-verified against the chain record.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 194 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "flag:Error-named", "label": "Error-named", "def": "Automated census category ('Error-named') from master_dataset. HEURISTIC — rule may over/under-match; audit before trusting.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "master_dataset auto-cat", "n": 1, "members": [ 404 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "name" }, { "type": "xmp:act1review_lone_jan16", "label": "xmp:act1review_lone_jan16", "def": "Exported alone on 2022-01-16 with no other file from its batch saved within days — an isolated timestamp (#448).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 448 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "glitch_type:merge_convergence", "label": "glitch_type:merge_convergence", "def": "Two creatures at the sides of the frame converge into a single creature in the middle over the loop — unique to #50.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 50 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "axis:identity_pairs", "label": "identity_pairs", "def": "This piece is one half of an explicitly identified two-piece pairing (identical files, mirrored designs, shared one-off colors, or matching typos). The pair relationships themselves are cataloged under the deliberate-pairs selection.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "glitch_types axes", "n": 1, "members": [ 130 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "relations" }, { "type": "xmp:robo_lone_afternoon", "label": "xmp:robo_lone_afternoon", "def": "Saved alone on 2021-09-24 at 14:25, more than four hours from any other save (#152).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 152 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "xmp:lone_spooky_dotted", "label": "xmp:lone_spooky_dotted", "def": "The only spooky piece in the 22.5 re-save batch, saved alone two hours after the main spooky session (#203).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 203 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "xmp:unique_psd_lineage", "label": "xmp:unique_psd_lineage", "def": "The only file in the collection with a traceable Photoshop DOCUMENT lineage (OriginalDocumentID + DerivedFrom metadata) — #300, saved on December 21, the solstice itself.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 300 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "xmp:late_ghost_straggler", "label": "xmp:late_ghost_straggler", "def": "The 17th ghost file with the 23.1 tool, exported alone on 2022-01-30 at 02:49 — 23 days after the automated 16-file burst of 2022-01-07 (#407).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "?", "n": 1, "members": [ 407 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "axis:background", "label": "background", "def": "A background-family observation from the ghost/review background census: which background pattern the piece uses (TEST wallpaper, binary tiling, skull emoji, lines) and whether it is the FIRST appearance of that background in the collection. Context for ideation, not a glitch by itself.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "glitch_types axes", "n": 1, "members": [ 489 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "color_speedup", "label": "color_speedup", "def": "A brief passage where color cycles/accelerates faster than the base animation.", "confidence": "eye+byte", "source": "the collector + delay table", "n": 1, "members": [ 491 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "standard_glitch", "label": "standard glitch", "def": "The standard frame-splice / frame-insertion glitch: a foreign frame is briefly spliced into the animation. the collector's baseline glitch.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 44, "members": [ 7, 11, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 53, 59, 61, 67, 71, 73, 79, 83, 97, 101, 103, 107, 109, 113, 127, 136, 142, 146, 148, 152, 158, 160, 166, 170, 172, 176, 182, 188, 190, 211, 244, 287, 291, 479 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "no_glitch", "label": "no glitch (NEGATIVE filter)", "def": "NEGATIVE FILTER. Pieces the collector explicitly says do NOT visibly glitch (\"no glitch\", \"doesn't glitch\", \"looks like a rainbow\"). Load-bearing negative set.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 30, "members": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 9, 51, 56, 58, 60, 75, 84, 86, 90, 92, 102, 115, 150, 166, 170, 175, 205, 281, 395, 409, 468, 474, 478, 490, 491 ], "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "morai_triplet", "label": "Morai Effect / triplet", "def": "The rare \"Morai Effect\": a triplet construction (#1 The Moirai). the collector: Morai is the template and the GANs are lossy derivatives of it.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 1 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "morai_echo", "label": "Morai echo", "def": "A faint echo of the Moirai triplet: hints of extra heads/eyes above or around the GAN. Count SOFT per the collector; #454 shows four not three.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 11, "members": [ 11, 12, 43, 44, 45, 73, 78, 100, 117, 123, 454 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "shimmer", "label": "shimmer", "def": "A shimmer effect that accompanies the standard frame-splice glitch (#7).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 7 ], "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "color" }, { "type": "anomalous_shape", "label": "anomalous shape", "def": "The GAN's silhouette/coloring briefly takes an anomalous shape (whale #5, shark #89, slender/thin #176).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 176 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "larger_eyes", "label": "larger eyes", "def": "Eyes noticeably larger than normal, sometimes only briefly (the collector marks it \"briefly\").", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 13, "members": [ 41, 43, 48, 66, 89, 97, 109, 449, 450, 451, 452, 455, 456 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "twin_entangled", "label": "twin / entangled", "def": "The piece is a twin / \"Entangled\" (the collector: Entangled is another word for twin, Pindar starting to think about quantum).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 5, "members": [ 19, 181, 192, 217, 300 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "gan_behind_background", "label": "GAN sits behind background", "def": "The GAN sits BEHIND the binary/background, when normally it sits in front of it.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 16, "members": [ 129, 130, 133, 138, 141, 143, 148, 153, 158, 161, 163, 168, 173, 174, 183, 185 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "naga_palindrome", "label": "naga / palindrome", "def": "A nagaGAN, one of the palindromes (robo drop 129-192). Some are not robots (cat #147, rat #162).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 9, "members": [ 129, 130, 141, 147, 159, 162, 174, 180, 192 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "color_flash", "label": "color flash", "def": "The color-flash effect: the GAN and background change color at once, uniformly or in waves.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 6, "members": [ 130, 133, 462, 463, 464, 497 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "sine_wave_background", "label": "sine wave background", "def": "During the color flash the binary background transforms into sine waves (#130, sine-wave morph #174).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 130, 174 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "speedup_effect", "label": "color speed-up effect", "def": "The animation / color cycle runs at a visibly sped-up (\"speed up\") rate.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 16, "members": [ 147, 192, 462, 463, 464, 485, 486, 487, 488, 505, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "still_eyes", "label": "still / static eyes", "def": "The eyes are totally static/stationary while everything else moves (#161, rimmed in bright green).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 161 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "hybrid_features", "label": "hybrid features", "def": "The GAN is a weird mixture of two drops' features (roboGAN + skullGAN, #175).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 175 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "ghost_eye_structure", "label": "ghostGAN eye structure", "def": "GhostGAN eye structure: a square with no pupil (robo eyes are square WITH pupils; skulls empty with a cut bottom-inside corner). First seen #187.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 187 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "eye_type_mixing", "label": "eye-type mixing", "def": "Within one piece the eyes cycle between skull / robo / ghost eye types (#191, #206).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 191, 206 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "costume", "label": "costume (spooky)", "def": "The GAN wears a costume or mask: ghost costume, Guy Fawkes/Anonymous mask, mummy, Count Dracula, pumpkin head, clown wig, burglar mask, pirate eye patch.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 10, "members": [ 193, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202, 204 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "precursor", "label": "precursor to later drop", "def": "The piece prefigures a later drop: #207 looks like a precursor to Solstice GANs (a #4 briefly on its chest).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 207 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "day_night_pair", "label": "day/night pair", "def": "A positive/negative day-night twin pair (#209 Solar / #300 Lunar dark twin, dotted-star background).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 209, 300 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "relations" }, { "type": "inverted_glitch", "label": "inverted glitch", "def": "An inverted glitch: the INSERTED frame is the color-NEGATIVE of the normal frames (the collector's definition). Byte-proven on the trio #231/#274 and doubled on #256.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 4, "members": [ 231, 256, 274, 479 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "double_inverted_glitch", "label": "double-inverted glitch", "def": "The piece is already black, so the (inverted) glitch frame is white. First of its kind (#256).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 256 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "space_invader", "label": "space invader icon", "def": "A space-invader icon on the shirt/head/background (spaceGAN motif).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 38, "members": [ 302, 310, 314, 315, 320, 328, 337, 340, 342, 349, 355, 365, 368, 370, 372, 373, 375, 377, 379, 383, 386, 396, 398, 401, 403, 408, 412, 421, 425, 426, 431, 439, 465, 466, 473, 474, 475, 476 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "dotted_star_background", "label": "dotted star background", "def": "Dotted \"stars in the sky\" background; the collector: all spaceGANs have this (#300, #302).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 300, 302 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "binary_background", "label": "binary background", "def": "Binary-pattern background (ghost-drop background taxonomy).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 65, "members": [ 303, 304, 306, 307, 308, 309, 312, 316, 317, 318, 319, 321, 323, 324, 326, 327, 329, 331, 333, 338, 341, 343, 344, 346, 348, 350, 352, 353, 358, 361, 363, 367, 376, 378, 380, 382, 385, 387, 388, 390, 391, 393, 395, 402, 405, 406, 407, 410, 413, 414, 415, 417, 418, 419, 420, 422, 424, 427, 429, 432, 433, 437, 441, 442, 444 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "skull_background", "label": "skull background", "def": "Skull-pattern background (ghost-drop background taxonomy).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 28, "members": [ 322, 335, 357, 360, 362, 364, 366, 369, 397, 404, 409, 411, 423, 435, 465, 466, 489, 490, 491, 492, 493, 494, 495, 496, 501, 502, 503, 504 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "podgan_background", "label": "PodGAN background", "def": "PodGAN background and eyes (ghost-drop background taxonomy).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 16, "members": [ 310, 314, 320, 328, 349, 355, 370, 372, 375, 377, 379, 398, 401, 412, 421, 431 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "test_written_word", "label": "Test written on body", "def": "The word \"Test\" written on the body and background (colored white/red in the review drop).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 39, "members": [ 301, 305, 311, 313, 325, 330, 332, 334, 336, 339, 345, 347, 351, 354, 356, 359, 371, 374, 381, 384, 389, 392, 394, 399, 416, 428, 430, 434, 436, 438, 440, 443, 467, 468, 469, 481, 482, 483, 484 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "beige_background", "label": "beige background", "def": "Beige background, first seen at #479/#480; the background morphs between beige and black.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 479, 480 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "line_background", "label": "line background", "def": "New \"line\" background, first at #485-488.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 4, "members": [ 485, 486, 487, 488 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "scanline_removal", "label": "scanline removal", "def": "New horizontal lines cut across the GAN, as if every other pixel row was removed (#489, #491).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 489, 491 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "rainbow_morph_prelude", "label": "rainbow-morph prelude", "def": "Skull-background pieces color-morphing through the rainbow; the collector calls them a prelude to the Quantum Glitch (#501-504).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 4, "members": [ 501, 502, 503, 504 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "color" }, { "type": "quantum_capstone", "label": "Quantum glitch capstone", "def": "#512: a wholly new, higher-definition GAN. The Quantum Glitch capstone, alluding to Pindar's next collection (quantum computers).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "color_gradient_off", "label": "color gradient off", "def": "The piece's color feels off relative to the drop's rainbow-gradient position (#357 feels very yellow where green/blue is expected).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 357 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "oval_eyes", "label": "oval eyes", "def": "Uncommon oval eye shape with large pupils (#467; #473-476 share these eyes).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 467 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "noun_eyes", "label": "Noun eyes", "def": "Noun (NounGAN study) eyes; #147 is the only GAN in the collection with them.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 147 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "named_after_solver", "label": "named after puzzle solver", "def": "The piece is named after a puzzle solver (#210, #211).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 210, 211 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "hidden_number", "label": "hidden painted number", "def": "A painted number briefly visible that no scanner catches (#165 \"8941\" sequentially; #207 \"#4\" on chest).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 165, 207 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "color_register_note", "label": "color register off", "def": "the collector flags the piece's color register as atypical (#49 not particularly smokey / warm not gray; #187 strange dark greens/browns/gray).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 49, 187 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "color" }, { "type": "name_meaning_question", "label": "name-meaning question", "def": "the collector flags the name's meaning as unexplained (#259 \"Why Hungry?\").", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 259 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "resembles_other_gan", "label": "resembles another GAN", "def": "the collector notes the piece is similar/akin to another named GAN (#194 Friendly Clown, #203 8 bit, #205<->#208).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 4, "members": [ 194, 203, 205, 208 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "lore_significance", "label": "lore significance", "def": "The piece carries special collection lore (#1/#2/#3 one of the first three bitGANs; #2 also one of the first burned in the Forge).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 3, "members": [ 1, 2, 3 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "puzzle_prize", "label": "puzzle prize", "def": "The piece is the prize of its drop's puzzle (#130 quantum nagaGAN).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 1, "members": [ 130 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "not_a_robot", "label": "naga not-a-robot", "def": "A nagaGAN that is explicitly NOT a robot but an animal (cat #147, rat #162).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 147, 162 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "anachronism", "label": "anachronistic feature", "def": "A feature appears before the drop that introduced it: #465/#466 are Spooky GANs (drop 2021.10.17) yet carry the invader, which did not appear until Ghosts in the Machine.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 2, "members": [ 465, 466 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "out_of_order", "label": "out of drop order", "def": "The piece appears out of order vs the act's normal ordering: #467-469 TestGANs should sit with the other Ghosts-in-the-Machine GANs.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 3, "members": [ 467, 468, 469 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "wrong_place", "label": "wrong place / misplaced", "def": "The piece matches no Seasonal/Ghost drop and is not grouped with the new Act-1-Review GANs, so it appears misplaced (#485-488 CryptoArtGAN colour-play; #497-500 high-definition robogans from the 2021.9.29.1202 drop).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 8, "members": [ 485, 486, 487, 488, 497, 498, 499, 500 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "black_background_ghost", "label": "black-background ghost", "def": "Like ghostGANs but the background is black instead of white (#501-504).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 4, "members": [ 501, 502, 503, 504 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "abstract_gan", "label": "Abstract GAN", "def": "One of the \"Abstract\" GANs new in Act 1 Review (#505-511).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 7, "members": [ 505, 506, 507, 508, 509, 510, 511 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "new_background", "label": "new background flag", "def": "the collector's per-piece newbg=Yes flag in by_essence.json: a novel/new background is introduced on this piece.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "collector notes", "n": 10, "members": [ 467, 468, 469, 473, 475, 476, 485, 486, 487, 488 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "doubling", "label": "doubling", "def": "A doubling observation mined from earlier chat: a second copy of a feature (head, figure, element) appears where one belongs. Mined text — check the piece's record for the specific claim.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 35, "members": [ 1, 8, 14, 57, 67, 71, 75, 121, 130, 134, 205, 209, 211, 212, 300, 304, 306, 309, 329, 357, 363, 375, 383, 407, 415, 446, 465, 466, 470, 472, 473, 477, 479, 480, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "pixelation", "label": "pixelation", "def": "A pixelation/degradation observation mined from earlier chat: part of the art dissolves into blocks or noise. Mined text — check the record for the specific claim.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 7, "members": [ 1, 5, 7, 129, 193, 209, 445 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "corruption", "label": "corruption", "def": "A corruption observation mined from earlier chat: the art visibly breaks down (smearing, tearing, channel damage). Mined text — check the record.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 9, "members": [ 1, 21, 75, 121, 130, 179, 281, 395, 449 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "differs", "label": "differs", "def": "A mined note that this piece DIFFERS from a source it should match (sheet vs chain, montage vs current art, or between files).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 25, "members": [ 1, 4, 9, 13, 23, 50, 71, 119, 151, 165, 175, 187, 191, 205, 207, 228, 231, 256, 274, 357, 363, 473, 479, 485, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "rainbow", "label": "rainbow", "def": "A mined color observation: rainbow/multicolor behavior in the art or a Rainbow label being tested against what the art shows.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 19, "members": [ 2, 56, 92, 96, 116, 128, 140, 150, 175, 179, 186, 204, 232, 326, 343, 423, 478, 490, 491 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "chat_corruption", "label": "corruption", "def": "Corruption noted in mined chat (visible breakdown of the art). Secondhand record — verify against the animation.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 49, "members": [ 4, 7, 14, 19, 32, 33, 48, 59, 66, 73, 119, 123, 124, 128, 129, 131, 150, 155, 175, 187, 191, 205, 228, 231, 280, 290, 300, 315, 363, 390, 404, 420, 445, 446, 457, 465, 466, 468, 473, 475, 479, 480, 504, 505, 507, 509, 510, 511, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_missing_element", "label": "missing_element", "def": "A mined note that an expected element (a feature, a file, a frame) is absent.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 34, "members": [ 4, 14, 21, 47, 57, 58, 66, 75, 88, 97, 119, 121, 128, 130, 133, 134, 143, 170, 172, 176, 182, 188, 190, 192, 342, 446, 457, 462, 463, 464, 472, 477, 497, 512 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "chat_color_flash", "label": "color_flash", "def": "A mined color-flash observation: frames where color jumps hard. Being re-verified by the 2026-08-28 color scan.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 6, "members": [ 4, 161, 165, 207, 281, 357 ], "kind": "glitch", "family": "color" }, { "type": "hidden_element", "label": "hidden_element", "def": "A mined note that something is hidden in the art (a shape, mark, or element not obvious at first look).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 2, "members": [ 4, 207 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_rainbow", "label": "rainbow", "def": "Rainbow/multicolor behavior noted in mined chat. Secondhand — verify against the animation.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 73, "members": [ 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 16, 17, 24, 28, 30, 31, 35, 39, 40, 43, 44, 47, 48, 49, 57, 58, 62, 66, 67, 68, 70, 71, 73, 75, 81, 88, 104, 113, 118, 123, 147, 152, 155, 160, 162, 166, 170, 173, 176, 190, 191, 203, 231, 244, 281, 287, 291, 309, 311, 357, 395, 407, 445, 457, 460, 465, 466, 468, 479, 485, 489, 493, 497, 505, 509, 511, 512 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "chat_flaming", "label": "flaming", "def": "A mined note testing the 'Flaming' label against the art (does it actually show fire/red?).", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 67, "members": [ 8, 9, 11, 13, 15, 19, 25, 31, 32, 34, 35, 39, 45, 46, 51, 56, 58, 60, 66, 72, 84, 86, 89, 90, 96, 102, 111, 113, 115, 117, 119, 122, 123, 143, 147, 150, 168, 175, 191, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 253, 314, 320, 349, 355, 357, 377, 379, 398, 401, 412, 421, 423, 431, 449, 458, 468, 470, 473, 491, 492, 494, 504 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "chat_no_glitch", "label": "no_glitch", "def": "Mined from old chat sessions ('chat_no_glitch'). Verify before trusting.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 81, "members": [ 11, 14, 16, 19, 20, 24, 30, 32, 33, 35, 43, 46, 47, 49, 66, 67, 69, 74, 87, 95, 111, 113, 117, 123, 125, 129, 135, 138, 141, 142, 146, 147, 149, 153, 159, 162, 165, 168, 174, 180, 188, 191, 192, 194, 204, 207, 231, 256, 274, 280, 287, 300, 314, 320, 323, 349, 355, 357, 377, 379, 398, 401, 412, 421, 423, 431, 465, 466, 473, 479, 480, 489, 501, 502, 503, 504, 505, 509, 510, 511, 512 ], "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "chat_glow", "label": "glow", "def": "A glow effect noted in mined chat.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 19, "members": [ 7, 21, 35, 39, 43, 67, 71, 73, 117, 123, 128, 143, 168, 170, 175, 191, 205, 449, 501 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "glitch", "label": "glitch", "def": "A mined note that the collector identified this piece as glitching (visual glitch present).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 26, "members": [ 13, 21, 121, 129, 144, 147, 150, 151, 159, 162, 174, 175, 179, 180, 203, 204, 205, 207, 208, 209, 228, 292, 407, 445, 474, 489 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "chat_mirror_invert", "label": "mirror_invert", "def": "A mined mirror/inversion observation (art flipped, reversed, or color-inverted relative to siblings).", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 52, "members": [ 14, 19, 32, 41, 57, 58, 81, 119, 129, 141, 142, 143, 145, 146, 147, 148, 150, 155, 187, 188, 191, 192, 210, 211, 213, 223, 228, 230, 231, 239, 256, 266, 270, 274, 285, 286, 294, 300, 326, 343, 357, 358, 390, 468, 479, 490, 501, 502, 504, 509, 511, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "anomaly_generic", "label": "anomaly_generic", "def": "A mined the collector observation that didn't fit a specific category — read the record text for the claim.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 9, "members": [ 32, 47, 119, 121, 192, 205, 268, 467, 501 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "robot_hybrid", "label": "robot_hybrid", "def": "A mined note that the piece mixes robot features into a non-robo drop.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 7, "members": [ 14, 32, 75, 130, 180, 390, 446 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "missing_element", "label": "missing_element", "def": "A mined the collector note that something expected is missing from this piece.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 2, "members": [ 32, 194 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "bytes" }, { "type": "chat_eye_anomaly", "label": "eye_anomaly", "def": "An eye anomaly noted in mined chat (shape, count, or behavior off the drop's normal).", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 1, "members": [ 41 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "chat_hybrid", "label": "hybrid", "def": "A mined note that the piece blends two drops' features.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 2, "members": [ 34, 55 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "channel_shift", "label": "channel_shift", "def": "A mined note of a color-channel shift (colors displaced as if RGB channels moved).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 1, "members": [ 57 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "flaming", "label": "flaming", "def": "A mined the collector note about flaming/fire behavior in the art.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 5, "members": [ 14, 57, 75, 208, 228 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "noise", "label": "noise", "def": "A mined note flagged as probable noise/uncertain during review — kept for provenance, low weight.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 5, "members": [ 56, 66, 140, 192, 468 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "glow", "label": "glow", "def": "A mined the collector note of a glow effect.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 14, "members": [ 24, 73, 123, 128, 154, 170, 175, 205, 311, 371, 380, 395, 429, 430 ], "kind": "cut", "family": "color" }, { "type": "chat_robot_hybrid", "label": "robot_hybrid", "def": "A robot-hybrid observation from mined chat (robot features outside the robo drop).", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 5, "members": [ 143, 148, 155, 187, 206 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_pixelation", "label": "pixelation", "def": "Pixelation/degradation noted in mined chat.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 9, "members": [ 143, 181, 203, 228, 301, 467, 468, 481, 512 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_noise", "label": "noise", "def": "Chat-mined text flagged as noise — kept only for provenance, no evidential weight.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 13, "members": [ 130, 161, 303, 328, 347, 357, 366, 367, 371, 390, 402, 407, 474 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_banding", "label": "banding", "def": "Banding (horizontal color bands) noted in mined chat.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 10, "members": [ 130, 133, 165, 207, 209, 300, 479, 480, 489, 491 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "mirror_invert", "label": "mirror_invert", "def": "A mined the collector note of mirroring or inversion.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 4, "members": [ 267, 385, 417, 445 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_distortion", "label": "distortion", "def": "Distortion (warping/stretching) noted in mined chat.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 3, "members": [ 130, 133, 473 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "blur", "label": "blur", "def": "A blur effect noted by the collector in mined chat (e.g. #264's blur possibly shared with Abosch #228).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 2, "members": [ 479, 480 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "chat_blur", "label": "blur", "def": "A blur effect noted in mined chat.", "confidence": "chat", "source": "chat_mined", "n": 2, "members": [ 286, 300 ], "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "claude_verified", "label": "claude_verified", "def": "Claude's frame-level verification of a the collector find (supporting record, not an independent claim).", "confidence": "agent", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "convergence_promise_piece", "label": "convergence_promise_piece", "def": "A piece where an independent finding converges with one of Pindar's two public 'hold on to this info' promises (#32, #119).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "glyph_TEST_wallpaper", "label": "glyph_TEST_wallpaper", "def": "The word TEST tiled as background/mouth-band. Ghost/review drop family texture — ruled NEVER payload (D9).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_band_candidate", "label": "glyph_band_candidate", "def": "Eye-band or body-band region flagged by the 2026-08-27 glyph sweep as letter-like. Most were ruled family texture in D9.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_digit_strip", "label": "glyph_digit_strip", "def": "Digit-like strip pattern flagged during the glyph hunts; texture-vs-payload criterion applies.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_in_art", "label": "glyph_in_art", "def": "Letters/numbers rendered inside the art (W25 register). Only the collector-confirmed carriers count as payload.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_palindrome_coherence", "label": "glyph_palindrome_coherence", "def": "#141's eye band reads '0110' — a palindrome — on the palindrome-named naga at position 001100: name, position, motion and glyph agree.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_robo_alphabet", "label": "glyph_robo_alphabet", "def": "The robo drop's native character set (0/box, I, 3, E, C, 8/B) used for faces and background tiling. Family grammar, not payload (D9).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "glyph_unverified", "label": "glyph_unverified", "def": "Glyph claim from an agent sweep not yet adjudicated by the collector's eye.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "ENTANGLED", "label": "ENTANGLED", "def": "the collector-ratified member of the Entangled class (D7): bodies consistently intermingled, matching Pindar's own 'Entangled' naming.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "PAYLOAD_confirmed", "label": "PAYLOAD_confirmed", "def": "the collector confirmed this mark as painted payload (not texture) under the all-frames rule.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "REJECTED_eye_remnant", "label": "REJECTED_eye_remnant", "def": "A glyph-like shape on this piece was proposed as a possible hand-painted mark, and the collector rejected it: the shape is a remnant of the creature's own anatomy (a degrading eye, antenna, or headgear), not an added mark. Recorded so the same candidate is never proposed again.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "TEXTURE_not_payload", "label": "TEXTURE_not_payload", "def": "the collector ruled the flagged pattern background/family texture, not a painted mark (D9).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "TWIN_ratified", "label": "TWIN_ratified", "def": "the collector-ratified member of the Twin class (D7): two side-by-side GANs whose bodies never merge (per-drop dialects).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "theme_breaker", "label": "theme_breaker", "def": "the collector's ruling that the piece breaks its own drop's theme (e.g. #206 — the only uncostumed spooky, D1).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "white_zero_eyes", "label": "white_zero_eyes", "def": "the collector (2026-08-28): shared eye TYPE — all-white inside, the eyes ARE the zero characters of the foreground binary. Members {130,133,141,174}.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "eyes" }, { "type": "named_entangled", "label": "named_entangled", "def": "Piece whose chain name contains 'Entangled' (the 15-member name family).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "needs_reframe", "label": "needs_reframe", "def": "Bookkeeping flag: record needs re-examination under a corrected method (e.g. after the all-frames rule).", "confidence": "meta", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "painted_mark_LOW", "label": "painted_mark_LOW", "def": "Painted-mark candidate graded LOW by a hunter; pending or failed adjudication.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "painted_mark_REJECTED", "label": "painted_mark_REJECTED", "def": "Painted-mark candidate rejected during hunting (with logged reason) — never re-hunt.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "painted_mark_adjudicated_rejected", "label": "painted_mark_adjudicated_rejected", "def": "Painted-mark candidate REJECTED by the collector on the all-frames adjudication page (D19). Never re-hunt.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "painted_mark_confirmed", "label": "painted_mark_confirmed", "def": "the collector-confirmed painted-mark carrier. Class roster (D19): #165 '81', #179 '10 . 00', #207 '4', #379 'AI'.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "painted_mark_location_confirmed", "label": "painted_mark_location_confirmed", "def": "the collector pinned the exact location/frames/reading of a confirmed painted mark (D15 #207, D16 #165).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "cut", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "painted_mark_reconfirmed", "label": "painted_mark_reconfirmed", "def": "A disputed painted mark RE-confirmed by the collector's eye over a hunter's texture argument (#379, D19).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "cut", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "painted_mark_unsure", "label": "painted_mark_unsure", "def": "the collector graded the candidate UNSURE on the adjudication page — parked, neither confirmed nor killed (#414).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "palindrome_triple", "label": "palindrome_triple", "def": "nagaGAN triple-coding: palindrome NAME + palindromic BINARY position + forwards-then-reverse animation (D8).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "glitch", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "quantum_vocabulary", "label": "quantum_vocabulary", "def": "Piece participating in the quantum thread: qubitGAN #130 -> Entangled pieces -> #512 Quantum Glitch (D7).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "lore" }, { "type": "still_eyes_class_update", "label": "still_eyes_class_update", "def": "Bookkeeping record on #161 tracking the still-eyes class roster as it grows. Current: {129,130,141,161,174,180,192}.", "confidence": "meta", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "text_TEST_wallpaper", "label": "text_TEST_wallpaper", "def": "TEST lettering tiled as wallpaper — ghost-drop family texture (same ruling family as glyph_TEST_wallpaper).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "text_binary_wallpaper", "label": "text_binary_wallpaper", "def": "Binary digits tiled as background wallpaper — family texture across robo/ghost drops.", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "painted" }, { "type": "texture_chest_emblem", "label": "texture_chest_emblem", "def": "Chest-emblem cell clusters on the torso (recurs on 12 skull pieces) — ruled family feature, not hand marks (D12).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "texture_not_payload", "label": "texture_not_payload", "def": "Generic ruling record: pattern survives the creature's dissolution or tiles full width => background texture (Addendum 3 criterion).", "confidence": "confirmed", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28", "kind": "observation", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "pair_ratification", "label": "pair_ratification", "def": "the collector's D2 grading confirming a deliberate pair (e.g. {165,207} confirmed with his 'suss — could be coincidence' caveat).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "glitch", "family": "relations" }, { "type": "pair_interpretation", "label": "pair_interpretation", "def": "the collector's interpretive note attached to a ratified pair (e.g. TRUE/FALSE as a statement about each piece's relation to its own drop).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "pair_adjudicated_rejected", "label": "pair_adjudicated_rejected", "def": "Pair candidate REJECTED by the collector in D2 (e.g. {150,179}: '179 is definitely a ghost — label fits').", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "forge_pair_explained", "label": "forge_pair_explained", "def": "Explains #204's anomalous Zombie SubType: #204 is a clown, not a zombie — but it was burnt in the forge as the required FLAMING half of a pair, and the pair it fed minted 'Cyber Zombie 10,366'. The Zombie SubType belongs to what it BECAME, not what it shows — the forge requirement explains the label anomaly.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "observation", "family": "chain" }, { "type": "mislabel_review_matches", "label": "mislabel_review_matches", "def": "Mislabel-review control graded 'matches' by the collector in D4 — the label accurately fits the art.", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "visual_validation_adjudicated_rejected", "label": "visual_validation_adjudicated_rejected", "def": "A Claude visual find REJECTED in the collector's ratification rounds (final ruling, supersedes any earlier 'survived' status).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "visual_validation_survived_candidate", "label": "visual_validation_survived_candidate", "def": "A Claude visual find that survived all-frames re-validation but is NOT yet the collector-ratified — candidate only.", "confidence": "heuristic", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "visual_validation_reassigned", "label": "visual_validation_reassigned", "def": "A visual find reassigned/retracted on re-validation — bookkeeping of the correction chain.", "confidence": "meta", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "visual_validation_creature_id", "label": "visual_validation_creature_id", "def": "the collector's corrected identification of what a creature actually is (e.g. #264: a DOG with tongue lolling, not a turkey).", "confidence": "eye", "source": "defs_backfill_2026-08-28b", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process" }, { "type": "glitch_name_no_glitch", "label": "glitch_name_no_glitch", "def": "Piece named 'Glitch' whose animation shows no visual glitch to the collector's eye — the name lies about the art. 17 skull pieces listed by the collector 2026-08-19.", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "glitch", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "label" }, { "type": "two_tier_glitch", "label": "two_tier_glitch", "def": "the collector-observed glitch with two distinct rhythms: widely spaced identical frames plus a separate short-spacing glitch set (#166).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "glitch", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "montage_mismatch_graded", "label": "montage_mismatch_graded", "def": "the collector graded this piece's art as NOT matching its tile in Pindar's official montage image (visual fact; the montage-selection theory itself was later closed).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "observation", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "montage_unsure", "label": "montage_unsure", "def": "the collector's montage-vs-art comparison came back UNSURE — the matching frame may not have been shown.", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "observation", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "montage_glitch_frame", "label": "montage_glitch_frame", "def": "The piece's montage tile shows an actual glitch frame of its animation (the collector's #19 finding).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "glitch", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "true_false_hypothesis", "label": "true_false_hypothesis", "def": "the collector's hypothesis that the TRUE/FALSE essences are an intentional labeling machine, not errors (earliest form of the classifier recipe).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "observation", "source": "chat_mining_2026-08-28", "family": "figures" }, { "type": "fibonacci_full_reverse_glitch", "label": "fibonacci_full_reverse_glitch", "def": "The complete backwards-Fibonacci frame-recurrence: one frame re-inserts with gaps shrinking 5,3,2,1,1. EXACTLY ELEVEN pieces carry it (148,152,158,160,166,170,172,176,182,190,287). the collector's ground-truth glitch definition.", "confidence": "eye+byte", "kind": "glitch", "source": "master_workbook_2026-08-28", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "frame_recurrence_glitch", "label": "frame_recurrence_glitch", "def": "The animation glitches under the ground-truth definition: a single frame re-inserts itself several times with real gaps between visits. 45 pieces qualify (the collector removed #5 as a detector false positive); the detector matches his eye on every other hand-check.", "confidence": "eye+byte", "kind": "glitch", "source": "master_workbook_2026-08-28", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "prime_rule_exception", "label": "prime_rule_exception", "def": "The ONLY exception to the first drop's hidden number rule (glitch iff prime-and-not-Fibonacci): #47 should glitch and does not. (#5 was cleared — the collector ruled it does not glitch, so it follows the rule.)", "confidence": "eye+byte", "kind": "glitch", "source": "master_workbook_2026-08-28", "family": "frames" }, { "type": "description_text_anomaly", "label": "description_text_anomaly", "def": "The contract description text embedded in the piece deviates from its drop siblings (e.g. #130 says 1024 animations where all others say 2048). A digit-string channel invisible to word-based sweeps.", "confidence": "confirmed", "kind": "observation", "family": "chain", "source": "2026-08-28d" }, { "type": "forge_pair", "label": "forge_pair", "def": "Chain-recorded forge pairing: this burnt piece and its named partner were consumed together to mint one SuperRare bitGAN (the output names the pair in its Burned-bitGANs trait). One pair was burnt but never forged.", "confidence": "confirmed", "kind": "glitch", "family": "relations", "source": "2026-08-28d" }, { "type": "still_eyes_adjudicated_no", "label": "still_eyes_adjudicated_no", "def": "the collector checked the piece for the still-eyes effect and ruled it does NOT have static eyes.", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process", "source": "2026-08-28d" }, { "type": "entangled_adjudicated_unsure", "label": "entangled_adjudicated_unsure", "def": "the collector re-reviewed and remains unsure whether the piece qualifies as entangled; parked.", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process", "source": "2026-08-28d" }, { "type": "pair_reason", "label": "pair_reason", "def": "States the specific reason a piece belongs to its deliberate pair (byte-identity, shared one-off effect, planted typo, day/night mirror...).", "confidence": "confirmed", "kind": "observation", "family": "relations", "source": "2026-08-28e" }, { "type": "quantum_group", "label": "quantum_group", "def": "Member of the quantum group: every piece touching quantum vocabulary or the quantum storyline (qubit, Entangled, Spin, the Prelude, the Quantum Glitch capstone).", "confidence": "confirmed", "kind": "observation", "family": "lore", "source": "2026-08-28e" }, { "type": "fib_run_boundary_case", "label": "fib_run_boundary_case", "def": "#291 carries the complete backwards-Fibonacci run plus one extra return — whether it joins the eleven is a pending classification decision.", "confidence": "eye+byte", "kind": "glitch", "family": "frames", "source": "2026-08-28e" }, { "type": "recurrence_classification_note", "label": "recurrence_classification_note", "def": "Detector-reconciliation note on a piece whose workbook glitch classification was revised (e.g. #147's naga mirror-loop counted as repeats).", "confidence": "confirmed", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process", "source": "2026-08-28e" }, { "type": "label_contradiction_confirmed", "label": "label_contradiction_confirmed", "def": "The collector confirmed a real label-vs-art contradiction on this piece (the label promises what the art contradicts).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "glitch", "family": "label", "source": "2026-08-28f" }, { "type": "label_question_resolved", "label": "label_question_resolved", "def": "A previously-open label question the collector resolved as NOT a contradiction (e.g. family styling explains the label).", "confidence": "eye", "kind": "bookkeeping", "family": "process", "source": "2026-08-28f" }, { "type": "prime_position_glitch", "label": "prime_position_glitch", "def": "A roboGAN whose 6-bit binary position (spelled in its name) is a prime that is not Fibonacci — the robo-drop form of Pindar's Prime Rule. All 15 such pieces glitch; positions 2,3,5 (prime AND Fibonacci) do not.", "confidence": "eye+byte", "kind": "glitch", "family": "frames", "source": "2026-08-28g" }, { "type": "prop:GlobalNumClass", "label": "global number-class", "kind": "observation", "confidence": "eye+byte", "family": "structure", "def": "The number-class of a piece scored on the WHOLE collection as one 0-512 sequence (fib/prime/square/odd-composite/even), independent of drop. Recorded as a property 2026-08-31 (Michael's request). Finding: the drop-native prime-not-Fibonacci glitch rule does NOT extend globally; global Fibonacci = 14 pieces {0,1,2,3,5,8,13,21,34,55,89,144,233,377} = the HODL/Named eleven plus #144, #233, #377.", "source": "D31_global_numclass" }, { "type": "deliberate_pair", "label": "deliberate pair", "kind": "glitch", "confidence": "eye+byte", "family": "name", "def": "Two pieces that carry the SAME one-off anomaly and nothing else does — a byte-identical file, a shared typo ('Primoridal','Gan','gltich','Raibow'), a shared flash, day/night, TRUE/FALSE. A defect on exactly two of 512 is a signature, not an accident. Exactly 11 pairs (pairs.json); #175 sits in two. Each record names the partner and the reason.", "source": "D2 ratified (9) + D43b census (2 new, data-verified)" }, { "type": "essence_color_word", "label": "essence is a BIP-39 color word", "kind": "observation", "confidence": "byte", "family": "color", "def": "The essence is a colour word on the BIP-39 list. The ten basic terms (black, blue, brown, gold, green, olive, orange, pink, silver, yellow) each occur exactly once; the list also carries bronze, copper, coral, cream, ivory, lemon, rose, salmon, sand and snow, of which rose (#446) and bronze (#493) are used. Widened from the ten on Michael's ruling. [audit 2026-09-17]", "source": "D46 deck census 2026-09-08" }, { "type": "no_essence_on_chain", "label": "no essence on chain", "def": "The chain record has no Essence trait (every skull and spooky piece). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 144 }, { "type": "filename_word", "label": "filename word", "def": "A seed-list word in the Arweave filename that is not a GANg/SubType/Type value anywhere and not in the piece's own metadata (autumn, winter, summer, spring, update, ancient, smooth, elder). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 86 }, { "type": "first_transfer", "label": "first transfer", "def": "When the token first left Pindar's wallet (the effective mint), from the chain. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 512 }, { "type": "filename_primordial_translation", "label": "filename primordial translation", "def": "Primordial written as 'ancient' (eight skulls) or 'elder' (#16) in the Arweave filename. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 9 }, { "type": "sheet_chain_difference", "label": "sheet chain difference", "def": "Pindar's sheet and the chain give different values for a field (29 pieces counting the Twin/Twins rename). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 29 }, { "type": "name_case", "label": "name case", "def": "'Gan' for 'GAN' (#175, #205) or 'SkullGAN' on chain (#4). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "filename_square_mark", "label": "filename square mark", "def": "The 's_' prefix on the square-numbered skulls that take letter c. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 9 }, { "type": "filename_typo", "label": "filename typo", "def": "Misspelled Arweave filename: gltich (#9, #73), raindow (#128). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "coburned", "label": "coburned", "def": "Burnt in the same transaction or block as another piece. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 10 }, { "type": "substitution_echoes_art", "label": "substitution echoes art", "def": "Where sheet and chain hold two real words, the substituted one echoes the art (collector, D59). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 6 }, { "type": "name_describes_visual", "label": "name describes visual", "def": "A word in the name describes something visible that the data cannot see (collector's ruling, D59). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 7 }, { "type": "essence_displaced", "label": "essence displaced", "def": "A piece holding a BIP-39 index that belongs to another slot in the 1-224 block, or one that gave its own slot away: #21 (bean for action), #57 (mistake for alpha), and robots #129, #131, #141, #189 holding block words. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 6 }, { "type": "selection:abnormal_hiddentype_eleven", "label": "selection: abnormal hiddentype eleven", "def": "A proposed eleven built from hidden-type abnormalities (run 15-16). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "candidate", "n": 11 }, { "type": "hiddentype_misplacement", "label": "hiddentype misplacement", "def": "A hidden-type letter that does not match the piece's number class (#119, #187, #193; and #32 by letter). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 4 }, { "type": "candidate_burn_pair", "label": "candidate burn pair", "def": "A proposed forge pairing not confirmed by the chain. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "candidate", "n": 2 }, { "type": "hiddentype_resolved", "label": "hiddentype resolved", "def": "Hidden-type letter differs between the chain and Pindar's own 1 Jan 2022 sheet, and the sheet has the correct class: a chain-side error he had already fixed (#32 'e', #119 'd'). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 2 }, { "type": "larger_eyes_adjudicated_no", "label": "larger eyes adjudicated no", "def": "Collector reviewed a larger-eyes candidate and rejected it. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 1 }, { "type": "filename_defect", "label": "filename defect", "def": "A structural slip in the Arweave filename, not a misspelling: five-digit binary on #143, unpadded number on #49, double underscore on #449. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "visible_creature", "label": "visible creature", "def": "A specific creature visible in the art, confirmed by name or by the collector. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 11 }, { "type": "name_stray_character", "label": "name stray character", "def": "A stray character in the name: the backtick on #66. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 }, { "type": "trait_value_typo", "label": "trait value typo", "def": "A trait value that misspells a value used elsewhere (Gltich, skulGAN, Raibow). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 4 }, { "type": "filename_square_unmarked", "label": "filename square unmarked", "def": "#121, the one letter-c square without the 's_' mark. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 }, { "type": "global_fibonacci_extra", "label": "global fibonacci extra", "def": "Piece number is Fibonacci in the 1-512 count beyond the skull drop. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "timing_hold", "label": "timing hold", "def": "A single frame held at 100 ms in an otherwise 0 ms file (#146, #479, #480). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 6 }, { "type": "description_anomaly", "label": "description anomaly", "def": "On-chain description differs from the drop's boilerplate. Seven are bespoke texts (#130, #147, #228, #246, #264, #282, #512); eight are defects in the boilerplate (#272, #301-#306, #400). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 15 }, { "type": "wrong_speed", "label": "wrong speed", "def": "Every frame at a delay other than the drop's standard (0 ms in later drops; 50 ms on #228). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 18 }, { "type": "hiddentype_anomaly", "label": "hiddentype anomaly", "def": "A hidden-type letter that is not one of a-e / A-E (the literal '32' on #32 and #161). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 2 }, { "type": "hiddentype_persistent", "label": "hiddentype persistent", "def": "Hidden-type letter is wrong in both the chain and Pindar's own sheet, so it was carried forward deliberately (#161 '32', #187 'C', #193 'F'). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "name_double_space", "label": "name double space", "def": "Two spaces before the counter where siblings have one. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 7 }, { "type": "essence_decoded", "label": "essence decoded", "def": "The printed essence is not a wordlist word but Pindar's index column points at one: #191 'err0r' -> 615 'error'. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 }, { "type": "theme_breaker_variant", "label": "theme breaker variant", "def": "A variant reading of the theme-breaker tag. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 1 }, { "type": "negative_frames_scan", "label": "negative frames scan", "def": "Frames that are the colour inverse of their neighbours, found by scanning every frame (#231, #256, #274, #479). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 4 }, { "type": "essence_transposed", "label": "essence transposed", "def": "Pindar's bip-0039 index column gives #259 index 181 = bird and #268 index 190 = bless, the reverse of the printed essences. The indices run in order; only the words swapped. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 2 }, { "type": "named_on_chain_only", "label": "named on chain only", "def": "Name trait on chain that the sheet leaves blank (#268, #379, #401). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "trait_key_misspelled", "label": "trait key misspelled", "def": "The trait's key is misspelled on chain: 'Subtype' on #383. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 }, { "type": "review_filename_group", "label": "review filename group", "def": "Pindar's own grouping of the Review drop by filename (reprise00-13, repriseaa, reprisebs, highdef, line, test, skullall, tributes). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 68 }, { "type": "review_odd_numbering", "label": "review odd numbering", "def": "A Review piece whose counter is binary or hex instead of n/512 (#457-#466, #497-#500). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 14 }, { "type": "chain_record_recovered", "label": "chain record recovered", "def": "The fourteen binary/hex-numbered Review pieces, once mislabelled as missing from the chain; found by mint slot (D53). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 14 }, { "type": "radix_corruption", "label": "radix corruption", "def": "Counter written in the wrong base: hex 0x20/0x21 on #465/#466. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 2 }, { "type": "mislabel_unsure", "label": "mislabel unsure", "def": "A label-vs-art contradiction the collector has not ruled on. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "candidate", "n": 1 }, { "type": "recurrence_adjudicated_no", "label": "recurrence adjudicated no", "def": "Collector reviewed a frame-recurrence candidate and rejected it. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "eye", "n": 1 }, { "type": "filename_smooth_mark", "label": "filename smooth mark", "def": "'smooth' in the filename, only on #5, #13, #89 (the Fibonacci primes). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 3 }, { "type": "double_mint", "label": "double mint", "def": "One piece exists at two mint slots (#390). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 2 }, { "type": "double_mint_detail", "label": "double mint detail", "def": "#390's two mints are not the same record: slot 519 has no traits and an external link; slot 583 has the traits and no link. [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 }, { "type": "archive_pointer", "label": "archive pointer", "def": "#272's description points at the 1 Jan 2022 capture of journal 015, which holds Pindar's working table with four extra columns (Decimal, Hidden Type, Strokes, bip-0039). [audit 2026-09-17]", "confidence": "data", "n": 1 } ], "_families": { "name": "Name anomalies", "label": "Label-vs-art contradictions", "frames": "Frame & timing", "color": "Color effects", "eyes": "Eye anomalies", "figures": "Figures & forms", "painted": "Painted marks & glyphs", "bytes": "File & byte forensics", "chain": "Chain & metadata", "relations": "Pairs & relations", "lore": "Lore & promises", "process": "Process & bookkeeping" } }